I've owned my Mana since June 2008, and love it. I have returned to biking with a 6 year gap, and wanted a street bike without the nutter power level that most bike reviewers seem to be pushing, with good looks, handling etc. I have not ridden a scooter before, and did not 'need' the auto box, but thought that it was innovative, and liked the ride during my 2 tests enough that i bought it (first was solo, 2nd with the girlfriend, now the missus, on the back). The auto gearbox is great, and I usually use it in manual in the sticks for a more interesting/involved ride, and auto (touring) around town. The sport mode makes the engine vibrate too much (too high revving), so i don't use this. I have not used 'rain' mode much, amazing as i live in Belgium ;o) so cannot comment on it's effect. Givi luggage is great (3 box set, mono key). The 'tank' storage compartment is not big enough for a full face helmet (at least not my Arai or Schuberth C3), but as it has my alarm box, intercom box, ipod, preload spanner, side stand 'plate', tyre gauge, bungee net, registration docs etc. in it, it is very convenient. quality of the bike, and controls are very good. (the bike has a handbrake, as the gearbox is always in neutral unless it is engaged). shame it is chain drive rather than belt drive, as it is a pain in the a**e to lube the chain without a centre stand (previous bikes were Transalp with centre staand, and R1100GS with shaft, so no probs here with lube-ing). the Aprilia screen is a barn-door so i am trying to get a smaller universal Givi screen to fit at the moment (difficult due to instrument cluster overhanging headlamp, but hopefully will work when i get the time: riding at 120km/hr+ is tiring due to wind pressure). I had heated grips fitted, but these are uncomfortable (large diameter) and make the bars vibrate to a painful degree so they are coming off! (will try alternative: perhaps oxford grips). mirrors are not wide enough, or perhaps my elbows are too big. no vibration in them though, will try some aftermarket ones soon.
The wife and I went to south of France from Belgium in summer 2008, and loved the ride, very comfy for both of us on the sweeping French back roads, but not so good on the autoroute (really needs a small screen to deflect the wind). Two-up performance is a bit more sedate due to extra weight, so may consider the Mana 1200 when it comes out later in 2009 (?).
Summary: a great looking, reliable bike with innovative transmission. Would definitely recommend, and buy one again (perhaps a less tall version for the missus?) Graham