Skip to content

Motorcycle Forums

You are in... Forums > Discuss This > MotoGP > Valentino Rossi undone by Ducati DNA

This is a discussion topic

This discussion topic is linked to an article on this site. You can navigate to the article by clicking on the article name in the first post.

Go to most recent reply

Anonymous

Joined:

Posts:

Matthew Birt  says:

Valentino Rossi undone by Ducati DNA

Valentino Rossi was unable to master Ducati’s fearsome Desmosedici machine because the bike behaved in a way that was totally alien to the riding style the nine-times world champion honed for almost two decades MotoGP paddock. That’s the view of new Ducati boss Bernhard Gobmeier, who has been charged with spearheading Ducati’s recovery after the Bologna factory endured a miserable lack...

Reply to this Topic  
  • Posted 112 days ago (29 January 2013 15:18)

Post a message in MotoGP

Fields marked with an asterisk * are required

   

Please note. You cannot submit more than 4000 characters as a message.

Upload image(s) from your computer (up to 3 images)

  1.  
  2.  
  3.  

Terms of use

Use of our community areas and forums is subject to important terms of use. By joining our community and using the features you agree to be bound by these terms. See terms of use below. 

Cancel
Farnarkle

Joined:

Jan 13

Posts: 74

Farnarkle says:

Ducs disease

Yes, Wosi, the Duc certainly did get worse by comparison to the Yams and Hondas; in fact, that rate was accelerating, and at no time moreso that Valencia 2010, when the very exact same Duc lost 2 secs a lap overnight! It went from a second in the race on Sunday to slower than a river barge overnight!  From second to slowest bike on the track one day later.

Whatever happened, it was pretty damn drastic. You'd have thought a development genius of Rossi's calibre would have been able to simply walk up to it and see that Stoner had taken two seconds away with him instantly, and fix it with his Swiss Army knife and some duct tape, but hey, shit happens.  Of course, from thereon it was all downhill for Rossi on the Duc (except L.S. 2012, when he didn't quite get as far as the downhill bit before falling off, again and as usual).

Reply to this Topic
doohanfan

Joined:

Jan 12

Posts: 656

doohanfan says:

qatar 2009

yes wosi
My argument that conditions in night races could change was completely overthrown because I didn't know (never knew actually) till what time the following day the 2009 qatar race was postponed, while you overlooking that the 2009  race as originally scheduled  was washed out by a desert storm when you made your absurd contention that track conditions couldn't change with night races, didn't detract from your argument at all. And yes, having been told by everyone including me that many things could affect times at the same track in different years, you then demolished me when I said that if you wished to consider rossi's 2011 fastest lap in isolation then stoner's 2009 time was faster anyway by recounting that the circumstances of the races were different.

I nearly wrote to the University of Sydney to request that they take back my degree, given the embarassment of being so bested. 

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Reply to this Topic
petedj

Joined:

Jan 11

Posts: 88

petedj says:

Talking b*ll*cks He would say that

The Ducati is never going to work with a 90 deg. V engine. It means the mass is too long and too spread out. To exagerate the effect it is like trying to race a chopper. The weight does not go forward enough to load the front under braking and does not load the rear enough under acceleration. i.e. corner entry and corner exit. Dovi. may be able to ride around it better than Rossi. Stoner certainly could but a re think of that engine is the way foreward. Difficult for a company that sells only 90 deg. V engined motorcycles.

Reply to this Topic
wosihound

Joined:

Jul 12

Posts: 1523

wosihound says:

Come now fuck-knuckle..

..you know Rossi had a shoulder injury that required surgery. Didn't stop him going faster in the race than Stoner did 2009..on his debut a few months later though did it?

Perhaps you can PM resident Dr. Doohanfan for a better understanding of an inflammation of the bursas: what is known as periarthritis; a very important tendinitis at the long head of the bicep; and the cartilage damage in the area that completes the skeleton of the shoulder blade [glenoid cavity]...

Then marvel at the sheer guts of competing all season long with such an injury AND a compound broken leg, when he could so easily have gone fishing?

To put it right, directly after your pathetic Valencia analogy, Rossi had a two-hour operation on his supraspinatus tendon and glenoid ligament at the Cervesi di Cattolica hospital.

The official MotoGP website quoted surgeons Dr Alex Castagna and Dr Giuseppe Porcellini as saying: "The condition of the shoulder was really critical: Valentino really had to be tough to keep racing with that kind of injury."

 

..and DF you conveniently senile old dingo sack. Aren't you forgetting wosi qualified his demolishing of your scrabbling impersoniation of a blind man looking for his lost stick, by pointing out that at the warm up on the Monday AFTER the downpour that you contended had washed the track of rubber and grip - while trying to make excuses for Stoner being slower than Rossi - all the top riders were at least half-a-second quicker than they had been in Sunday WUP prior to the race being postponed. The track was in fact faster you antiquated muppet.

University of Sydney my arse..  
 

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Reply to this Topic
Hedgehog5

Joined:

Aug 02

Posts: 2064

Hedgehog5 says:

Saturn...

"Thank you for that !   It explains perfectly why Rossi and Burgess were unable to succeed with the Desmo."

Yay... you're getting there... as has been said over & over they needed to improve more than Yamaha & Honda to close the gap... & it's a gap that they're constantly trying to stretch.

2008 to 9 the gap got bigger with the new CF bike as Stoner dropped to 220 points but they held it at that the next year (despite the crashes) effectively improving inline with the Japanese factories... then Stoner left.

"Well done!"

[This Reply has been modified by the Author]

Reply to this Topic
RobinC

Joined:

Sep 11

Posts: 4

RobinC says:

Ducati

I hate to interupt the banal arguments from the various rider fans, but what Mr Gobmeier is saying is an admission that the Ducati DNA is contrary to what all the other bikes are, that is the very successful other bikes, but I don't see any indication in his statement that that is either wrong or that they intend to change it!

If that Ducati DNA was any good then any top level rider would be able to ride it quickly, obviously some quicker than others, but they could'nt, end of argument. I'm disapointed that Mr Gobmeier has either failed to see or at least admit that that Ducati DNA is not conjusive to a consistant fast racing motorcycle and has made no comment or any refernce to their intent to change it. Merely waiting and hoping for another Stoner or a Hailwood is not the development route to building a competitive racing motorcycle.This is sadly not a good sign of how successful Ducati will be this season.

Reply to this Topic
weskit

Joined:

Jun 10

Posts: 426

weskit says:

I'm beginning to like Mr Gobmeier

I was originally just spouting rubbish when describing Rossi as a whimsical prima donna who spent his two years at Ducati demanding the factory build him new random parts every week, but turns out it was actually TRUE. All you need to know about Rossi is contained in the following quote: "Because after what all I did for Yamaha, they put me in a team, a very strong teammate". So after paying him millions over 5 years and providing him with a championship winning bike he thinks they owe *him* and have no right to hire a rider who might actually be faster. Hard to imagine a more self-serving and arrogant attitude. Ducati have wasted two years of development thanks to him, good riddance.

Reply to this Topic
wosihound

Joined:

Jul 12

Posts: 1523

wosihound says:

Rubbish..

2010..more crashes & less wins from 18 starts rather than 14 in 2009, is holding the gap?

Rossi was faster than Stoner 2009 at Qatar on his debut. It could be argued he pegged the gap back initially and after all the in-season testing of ways to make the CF bike work and losing ground, pegged it back again with his development direction when the new ALU chassis was reluctantly introduced.

I don't see Ducati rushing to bring back the CF bike Casey begged for, that presided over a marked decline in his fortunes.. do you?

Reply to this Topic
ElDiablo73

Joined:

Aug 12

Posts: 254

ElDiablo73 says:

Doohafan

Obviosly Doohanfan, you lack humor, my intentions are to make some fun at the situations described below, no mean to disrespect anybody personally as we don't know each other.

Now, talking business, you want us to accept the vast superiority of your down under mate because he mastered a difficult bike forgeting that it was the faster and the better equiped (Bridgestones) of the pack in 2007.

2nd some juvenile blokes state some stupidities about Colin Edwards on the Cube being also fast in the straight line, are u serious? Edwards vs Rossi's or Stoner's talent?

3d, you are not the only one following MotoGP or 500 before 2006 (I am 40) and obviously you are not the only one with some racing experience or whatsover... I can understand that suddenly other folks interrupt your urge to impress younger audience but as you can understand (I hope), Stoner is gone and soon will be forgotten, I also don't think much of Criville or Roberts Jr. and I will probably also forget Lorenzo if he stays with only 2 WT. But I will surely remember Doohan (as you do) and Rossi for the obvious reasons.

Again, we have to accept - because you say so - that Stoner is the best rider of all times with 2 WChampionships... and then you die to convince everybody else that 7+2 World Titles where won just because of some random planet alignement... sure mate. You totally blew me there... AUT VIAM INVENIAM AUT FACIAM
 

Nationalism? Obviously I am not the Australian guy supporting my fishinmate at no cost... and obviously I am not Italian... plus I was a huge Doohan fan myself so no nationalisms here buddy. Do you have any objections regarding that the future of MotoGP is Spanish? Can you please state what other country can and will monopolise the game? Australia, nope, USA? France? Italy? UK??? Pedrosa, Lorenzo, Marquez vs Rossi (hope he wins at least 1 more), Dovi, Spies, etc... 3 out of 4 aliens are Spanish, what are the odds?

Reply to this Topic
getagrip

Joined:

Mar 12

Posts: 2

getagrip says:

Well done Gobmeier!

Was thinking of some long winded answer, but the long and short of it seems to be, Ducati built a bike that they admit no one could ride fast until they by chance signed Casey Stoner, and Vale has done the best job of anyone since.

And the chances of stumbling upon another title winner with this bike are?

Reply to this Topic

Page

Compare Insurance

Save money by comparing quotes. It's quick and easy

Motorcycles for sale

 

It's only £13.99 to advertise your motorcycle on MCN

Sell your Motorcycle