Put the brakes on bike theft: Best motorcycle disc locks tested by the experts at MCN

Anybody who rides motorcycles understands the Old West adage, “There’s nothing worse than a horse thief”. The nicer your bike, the more chance someone with looser morals agrees. Motorcycle disc locks and even traditional U-locks are a simple way of adding a layer of security to your trusty steed.

Security you can carry is convenient and easy to use. The premise is simple. Just lock it through the front brake disc to prevent the wheel from turning. No security feature is 100% effective. But if they add enough time and hassle to remove, that’s success enough. They won’t prevent the bike from being physically lifted up and put in the back of a van, but they’ll prevent all but the most determined (and burly) bike thief.

Watch our top five ways to keep your bike safe in this video

Disc locks in more detail

Built-in steering locks aren’t particularly effective. They can often be defeated with a screwdriver, allowing a thief to push it elsewhere, buying them time to bypass the key and start the bike. With a disc lock in place, they can’t roll the bike anywhere.

While a motorcycle disc lock isn’t perfect on its own for long term storage, it’s a great addition if you commute to work or are running errands. Many disc locks feature high decibel alarms when someone tampers with your bike. It’s yet another layer that when added up, can make a difference.

What features should a motorcycle disc lock have?

In addition to the lock itself, some disc locks also feature Bluetooth location services and high-intensity alarms, to draw attention to larcenist tampering. Many also come with a safety lanyard or brightly-colored cable to remind you the lock is there. You’d be surprised by how many people forget and are greeted with a bang indicating a damaged brake disc or caliper.

You may want to take into account the British non-profit organization Sold Secure, which offers approval of tested products by the Master Locksmiths Association and rates products by their attack resistance. Look for Motorcycle-rated products with Gold or Diamond being the second-highest and highest standards, respectively. If it’s good enough for the English, it’s likely good enough for New York.

Here is a selection of motorcycle disc locks to keep your bike safe and sound.

Tried and tested but Carl Stevens for six months- "It has never been more important to keep your machinery as safe as possible, and a good, solid disc lock is a great way to keep things secure. The Defiant Disc Lock from Squire is a great option, achieving the very highest Sold Secure grading levels with Diamond Approval, meaning that it has been designed to withstand the most brutal attacks, including angle grinders and power tools."

"It feels incredibly secure and well-built, with a snug fitment to the brake disc. Yet even though the defiant is impressively effective in it's security, the best thing is that it's small and weighs in at just 1.1kg, so it fits easily into a rucksack and isn't noticeable either."

"The only real drawback comes in the form of the asking price, as on the one hand, $265 is a lot of money for a disc lock. Yet it's one of the more rugged locks i've ever used and if it saves your pride and joy, it's worth every penny"

Pros

  • Feels solid and secure
  • Diamond Sold Secure Approval

Cons

  • It's expensive
  • Quality
    5.0
  • Value
    3.0
Weight 1.1kg
Alarmed? No
Construction Hardened steel
  • 25mm shackle
  • 6 pin dimple key cylinder
  • Anti-drill, anti-pick and anti-bump technology
  • Neoprene pouch included
Tried and tested by Jim Blackstock - "This is a very simple yet effective disclock. In its very basic form, it’s a solid lock that will prevent the bike from being ridden away and offers a hefty visual deterrent. On a higher level, it has a piercing (I know, I tested it) alarm to draw attention if anyone tampers with the bike and further, you can set and unset the alarm and change its characteristics from your smartphone. Any one of those makes it worth considering; all three makes it a handy weapon in the war against theft."

Pros

  • Solid mechanical lock
  • 120dB alarm with Bluetooth control
  • Optional chain attachment

Cons

  • None we can think of
  • Quality
    5.0
  • Value
    4.0
Weight 770g
Alarmed? Yes
Construction Stainless steel
  • 120dB alarm
  • Removable and changable alarm module
  • 3 keys
Tried and tested by Richard Newland for five months - "If you want something that looks like you’ve got a wheel clamp attached to your disc, then this probably isn’t for you – but if you want a highly portable tough and noisy disc lock that’s Sold Secure Motorcycle Gold standard certified, then read on."

"The XA14 is certainly compact, but it’s got the minerals to slow a thief down and if the light-fingered scumbag decides to have a good go at removing it, they’ll also have the 110dB siren to contend with while they meddle."

"The lock feels solid and well-made, is attractively bold in bright yellow (black also available), comes with three sturdy keys (and a key code in case you lose them all) that won’t bend in your pocket, and boasts a fat 14mm locking pin to keep it in place. Being small, it’s easy to slip into a tankbag, pannier or rucksack – although it’d be nice it if had its own little pouch to stow away in."

"You get a reminder cord, which I know from bitter experience should always be used, and the alarm battery is a USB rechargeable unit, so you don’t need to buy a box of button batteries with it and can even charge it while riding if you have a power point on your bike. Tidy bit of kit."

Pros

  • Small and easy to carry with you
  • High-security
  • The alarm is loud!

Cons

  • Looks weedy
  • No carry-pouch
  • Quality
    5.0
  • Value
    5.0
Weight 739g
Alarmed? Yes
Construction Forged stainless steel
  • 110dB alarm
  • Sold Secure Gold
  • Compact and portable
  • 14mm locking pin
Tested by Gareth Evans over 1500 miles. This reassuringly heavy little lock has been a grand companion. It fits in my my jacket pocket, making it super-practical for trips when I’m without luggage.

I love its simplicity – all you need to do is push the key down and the lock barrel sinks into the casing. Rotate key and the alarm beeps loudly to let you know the 10mm pin is armed, which is mostly useful and occasionally irritating at night. I’ve set the alarm itself off for testing, and that thoroughly unpleasant experience highlighted this is one LOUD alarm.

Biggest drawbacks? The battery is extremely difficult to access, it’s not ‘Sold Secure’ and it’s not cheap.

Pros

  • It's easy to use
  • Loud alarm
  • It feels sturdy
  • Fits easily pockets and lugguage

Cons

  • Not Sold Secure
  • Battery is hard to access
  • Quality
    4.0
  • Value
    2.0
Weight Unknown
Alarmed? Yes
Construction Alloy metal
  • 110dB alarm
  • Rechargeable lithium ion battery
  • Twin Spark Lock Chassis For Double Strength And Cut Resistance
Tested by Simon Brown over 1000 miles. "Tiny disc lock packing a 120dB alarm, the KS6 is small and light (just 263g), making it more likely you’ll take it with you. The 5.5mm steel pin goes through a brake disc’s ventilation hole, rather than between the disc and the carrier, but it’s easy to fit and remove — press the pin down once (one beep) to arm or halfway (two beeps) to disarm the siren.

The only issue is recharging – quite a palaver to get to the MicroUSB socket. At least it only needs doing every month or two. A portable, affordable and convenient first line of defence."

Pros

  • Small and light
  • Easy to use
  • The alarm is really loud

Cons

  • Not the easiest to charge
  • Quality
    3.0
  • Value
    4.0
Weight 300g
Alarmed? Yes
Construction Steel
  • 120dB alarm
  • Rechargeable battery
  • Weatherproof
Tried and tested by Justin Hayzelden for seven months - ""The rubber coating has a soft, malleable feel which helps prevents damage to delicate parts like discs, wheels and fairing panels. This is something I really like as the X1 is most effective when threaded around spokes and through brake discs to give any would-be thieves a time consuming puzzle. The self-sealing silicone cover over the lock barrel to prevent water and grit getting inside is a well thought through feature too. "

"I used to carry a substantial lock and chain whenever I needed peace of mind on the go, but it was an awkward and heavy lump to lug about, especially when all I had was a rucksack. The X1 only weighs 1,500 grammes (on my scales) and measures just 265 x 178mm, meaning I can chuck it in my top box, tank bag, or any other piece of luggage for that matter, without worrying about the extra weight."

Read Justin's full Litelok X1 Moto review

Pros

  • Light and easy to use
  • Rubber coating protects surfaces
  • Feels tough

Cons

  • None we have found
  • Quality
    5.0
  • Value
    4.0
Weight 1.5kg
Alarmed? No
Construction "Barronium" ceramic composite armour fused to a high tensile steel core
  • Certified Sold Secure Bicycle Diamond and Sold Secure Motorcycle Diamond
  • soft coating won't damage your bike
  • Repels angle grinder attacks

Frequently asked questions

Are disc locks better than padlocks?

Yes. Disc locks are usually more secure than a padlock since the locking mechanism is harder to access with basic tools like bolt cutters.

Where should the disc lock be placed?

A disc lock should be placed with the locking bolt through holes in the brake disc, stopping the wheels being able to turn. The reminder lanyard or cable on the handlebar grip will remind you that it’s active.

Are disc locks theft proof?

No motorcycle security is 100% effective. But the right disc lock makes your motorcycle more work than it’s worth to steal. All locks (hopefully) buy enough time for a thief to look elsewhere.


How MCN tests security products

The MCN team of expert journalists have decades of experience over hundreds of thousands of miles. We don’t torture test anything. We use it just like you do in the real world and in all conditions to deliver impartial security product buying advice.

MCN covers countless miles each week and tries lots of options in a short space of time. We quickly discover which security products work great, which ones don’t and why.

We only feature security products we’ve extensively tested. Comparison security products will be included if deemed important and relevant. Testing is ongoing and we will continually add gear and products to our site.

To find out more, head to our dedicated page explaining how we test motorcycle products.

Scoring explained:

Products are given a score from 1 to 5 stars. Beyond the ratings tab, you’ll find in-depth info on product and gear performance and attributes.

  • 1 star – Avoid at all costs.
  • 2 stars – Barely acceptable.
  • 3 stars – Average or adequate.
  • 4 stars – Above average.
  • 5 stars – Excellent performance.

To find out more, head to our dedicated page explaining how we test motorcycle products.

- Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us.