Driver is now denying blame but can I still claim?
I was knocked off my bike when a driver changed lanes on a roundabout. At the scene he was very apologetic and said I could claim on his insurance but now he’s saying I was the one who was in the wrong lane and that the accident was my fault. Can I still try to claim on his insurance?
Ed Green, email
- Kawasaki announces Z900 and Z650
- 30 years of the Suzuki RGV500
- New Yamaha R World teaser video
- Live from Intermot: Motorcycle launches and stunning debuts
- BSB: JG Speedfit Kawasaki set to quit BSB?
Answered by Andrew Campbell, Solicitor and author of the MCN Law column.
There is a lot of confusion around the role of insurance companies in the claims process. When you are hit by a third party and you make a claim against that driver’s insurance you are actually suing that other driver, usually for negligence, and that driver is being indemnified by his or her insurance company.
If the other driver denies your allegation, even if he admitted liability at the scene, then you would need to pursue the matter in court to seek damages. In civil court the test which the judge will use is whether, on the balance of probabilities, your allegation of negligence is more likely to be true than not. It is for the claimant to prove his claim rather than for the defendant to prove their defence so if the court was unable to decide then your claim would fail.
The way to persuade the court that your version of events is accurate would be to provide as much evidence in support of your version of events. Usually this will mean getting statements from witnesses, the police or in serious cases even forensic reconstruction evidence, though your solicitor should be able to advise you as to whether this is appropriate as it can be very expensive.